Why Some Etsy Reviews Don’t Show Up
Discover why Etsy reviews sometimes don’t appear, from eligibility windows and policy removals to technical glitches, missing orders, and filtered star ratings.
I opened a new Etsy shop about a month ago selling 100% handmade embroidered items (mainly aprons). I got a few sales early on, but after that my views and visits dropped sharply, and I’m only seeing a couple of search visits per day with very few favorites or messages.
Is it normal for a new Etsy shop to get an initial burst and then slow down, or could something be wrong with my listings (SEO, titles, tags, photos, or descriptions) that’s limiting my visibility? Also, I ship internationally from Türkiye using DDU—could that be reducing conversions, and if so what should I adjust?
Hi! Yes—what you’re describing is really common for new Etsy shops: Etsy often gives new listings/shop a short “test” period where they get more impressions, then traffic drops back until your listings prove they convert (clicks, favorites, add-to-carts, sales, good delivery experience). So it’s usually not that something is “wrong,” but you’ll want to tighten your Etsy SEO + conversion pieces and make international shipping feel low-risk for buyers.
Here’s what I’d fix first (highest impact):
What to adjust:
A quick self-check: if your titles/tags are mostly “handmade apron, embroidered apron, apron,” you’ll get buried. If they’re “Personalized Embroidered Linen Apron, Custom Name Apron, Floral…” you’ll show up in narrower searches where you can actually win.
If you want, paste one of your listing titles + all tags + your main photo (screenshot is fine), and tell me your top buyer countries (US/EU/UK). I’ll suggest a tighter title/tag set and shipping wording that fits DDU without scaring buyers off.
Related questions
I sell cute pastel floral apparel on Etsy and want to add a very different style. Will mixing niches hurt Etsy SEO/visibility, or should I open a second shop?
I have a new Etsy shop with no warnings, but Etsy is holding my payouts. What triggers a payment reserve, and how can I release payouts sooner without tracking?
I opened a new Etsy shop and Etsy is holding my funds for 14 business days. Is this a temporary reserve for new shops or a permanent payout schedule?
I’m in India and want to sell digital downloads on Etsy as an individual. What verification and tax info does Etsy typically require for setup and payouts?
I started my Etsy shop in early September and have about nine listings. My conversion rate is 1.4%—is that normal for a new shop, and how can I improve it?
I sell digital downloads on Etsy and got a 3-star review because the buyer expected a translation. Will Etsy remove it, or should I move on?
Related posts
Discover why Etsy reviews sometimes don’t appear, from eligibility windows and policy removals to technical glitches, missing orders, and filtered star ratings.
Get ready to open a successful Etsy shop with smart product ideas, branding, pricing, photos, SEO keywords, fees, policies, and launch marketing already planned.
Discover how more Etsy reviews boost buyer trust, improve your shop’s SEO, increase conversion rates, and drive consistent sales growth for your listings.
Learn how to create private Etsy custom listings step by step, reserve items for one buyer only, manage custom orders, protect pricing, and boost shop sales.
Streamline batch shipping on Etsy with a simple system that saves time, cuts postage costs, automates labels, and boosts order accuracy for happy repeat buyers.
Holiday shipping deadlines guide for Etsy sellers with USPS, UPS, FedEx cutoff dates, processing times, packaging tips, and planning strategies to avoid late deliveries.