How do I create an Etsy discount code that only works for first-time buyers?

Hi! Unfortunately, Etsy doesn’t currently let you make a shop promo code that’s restricted to “first-time buyers only,” and there’s no built-in setting to make one code automatically “one-time use per customer” (like 1 redemption per Etsy account). So if you publish one shared newsletter code, a buyer can use it again on a later order if they still have the code.

If you want the closest “first-order only” behavior, these workarounds are what most Etsy sellers do:

• Send unique, single-use codes instead of one public code. Create a batch of different Etsy promo codes (same discount, different code text) and have your email platform send one code per new subscriber. When you see a code used, you can retire/stop that specific code (or just let it expire).
• Make the code harder to reuse: set an end date (short window like 3–7 days), add a minimum order, and limit it to full-price items (exclude your loss-leaders / bestsellers if needed). This doesn’t enforce “first-time,” but it reduces repeat abuse.
• Monitor redemptions in Shop Manager → Marketing → Sales and Discounts. If you notice repeat use by the same buyer, you can end that promo code and issue them a replacement (or simply stop honoring that type of offer going forward).
• Alternative approach: keep the newsletter code small (ex: free shipping or a modest % off) and use a better “thank you” offer for second purchases. Etsy’s “thank you” targeted offer is naturally aimed at repeat buyers, so your bigger incentive can live there instead of in a reusable signup code.

One important reality check: even if Etsy did limit by account, a determined person can sometimes place orders from a different Etsy account, so the best practical protection is unique codes + short expiry + sensible minimums. If you tell me what email service you’re using (Mailchimp/Klaviyo/Flodesk/etc.), I can suggest the simplest way to manage unique codes without it turning into a full-time job.